What makes BoMill different?

Grain sorting technologies use different information to decide how grain should be separated. What sets single-kernel sorting apart is what that decision is based on.

From knowing to acting

In our Know Your Grain series, we looked at a simple idea: a grain lot contains more information than its average tells you. Two lots with the same average protein can be made up of very different kernel populations.

Knowing that is useful. Acting on it is a different question.

This article explains how BoMill InSight™ acts on that information, what its sorting decision is based on, and where it fits in a grain-processing line.

What happens to each kernel

InSight analyzes and sorts grain kernel by kernel. Every kernel goes through three steps.

  1. It is handled individually. Grain enters the machine and is distributed so that each kernel can be handled on its own. The kernel is then guided through the system under controlled movement.

  2. It is analyzed. Near-infrared light passes through the kernel. This is called Near-Infrared Transmission (NIR-T). The light generates information about the kernel's internal characteristics, which InSight uses to make a relative, protein-related measurement. This lets kernels be compared with each other and classified.

  3. It is directed to one of two fractions. Because the kernel stays under controlled movement, the system knows which kernel it has analyzed and where that kernel is. Based on the classification, the kernel goes to Fraction A or Fraction B.

Nothing is added to the grain and its protein is not changed. Kernels are analyzed and directed. One incoming lot becomes two fractions with different protein characteristics.

How the sorting decision is made

The machine does not decide on its own what "good" means. That is set for each application.

Based on the intended application, selected protein-related sorting criteria are applied to classify each kernel and direct it into one of two fractions.

The resulting fraction sizes and characteristics depend on the protein distribution in the original lot and the selected sorting threshold.

What single-kernel sorting means in practice

Most grain quality decisions are based on samples. A sample is measured, the result is treated as representative of the whole lot, and the lot is handled accordingly. For many decisions, this works well.

Single-kernel sorting works differently. Each kernel's own classification decides where that kernel goes. Instead of treating the lot as one average, you treat it as a population that can be divided.

The total amount of grain does not change. What changes is how it is distributed between the two fractions, and therefore what each fraction can be used for.

Different sorting methods, different signals

Grain processors already use several cleaning and sorting methods. Each one bases its decision on a different signal.

A Closer Look At How Single Kernel Insight Creates New Possibilities In Grain Sorting

Physical properties such as size or density can be related to composition, but the relationship is not consistent. It varies with the crop, the lot and the growing season.

So when the goal is to divide grain by protein, InSight bases the sorting decision on protein-related information from each kernel. When the goal is to remove impurities, defects or foreign material, other methods are designed for that job.

1791460534641
Conventional optical sorting primarily addresses differences in grain appearance, such as discolouration, visible defects and foreign material, while some systems also use additional wavelengths to identify other characteristics.

How the kernel is handled also differs.

Conventional optical sorters typically inspect grain as it falls freely through the sorting area, and selected kernels are ejected at high speed. In InSight, each kernel is guided individually and stays under controlled movement from measurement to sorting. Only the kernels selected for separation are diverted.

Different problems, different tools

Cleaning, optical sorting and composition-based sorting solve different problems:

  • Cleaning removes unwanted material based on physical characteristics.

  • Optical sorting addresses visible, external differences such as discolouration, damage and foreign objects.

  • InSight separates clean grain into two fractions by relative protein characteristics.

Because they address different quality characteristics, they can complement each other in the same process. Whether a line needs one, two or all three depends on the raw material, the quality challenges and what the process needs to achieve.

The idea of dividing grain by protein is not new. Maltsters, for example, often segregate barley shipments by protein and malt them separately. Single-kernel sorting applies the same logic within a lot, kernel by kernel.

Sorting toward a target, not toward "better"

It is tempting to think of sorting as a way to make grain "better." For protein, that is rarely the right way to think about it. The right grain depends on what it will be used for.

· Bread-making wheat: a minimum protein level may be required. Here, higher protein can be the target.

· Malting barley: protein may need to remain below a specified maximum. Here, lower protein can be the target.

Same measurement, opposite directions.

The target is not always a different average, either. Sometimes it is a more uniform fraction. Sorting can split a broad protein distribution into two narrower ones, so each fraction varies less from kernel to kernel than the original lot.

InSight sorts according to the quality requirements of a specific application. But achieving the desired quality is only part of the equation. The next question is whether that separation creates enough value to justify the investment.

Where InSight fits in a processing line

A simplified line with InSight looks like this:

Grain intake → Cleaning / pre-cleaning → Existing sorting (where relevant) → BoMill InSight → Fraction A / Fraction B → Separate storage → End use

Before InSight: grain should be at least pre-cleaned.

Where it goes: InSight can be integrated into existing or new lines in flour mills, maltings and other grain-processing facilities. The best integration point depends on the application, the available space, the required capacity, existing conveying equipment, and what will happen to the two fractions.

Capacity: the same kernel-by-kernel principle is used across the portfolio.

· BoMill InSight™ Single: approximately 2 t/h, for smaller volumes, specialty applications, testing, or starting at a lower capacity.

· BoMill InSight™ 30: up to 30 t/h.

· BoMill InSight™ HiFlex: a modular high-capacity concept in which multiple sorting units operate in parallel, up to approximately 200 t/h.

Utilities and space: requirements such as utilities, conveying and plant automation depend on the configuration and are defined for each project.

Why two fractions matter

Beyond the machine itself, an important practical consideration is that one stream of grain becomes two.

Each fraction needs somewhere to go:

  • Storage: can the fractions be kept apart?

  • Conveying: can each stream reach its destination without being mixed again?

  • Tracking: can each fraction be identified through the process?

  • Use: is there a clear destination for each fraction, in your own process, for a customer or for sale?

When these answers are clear, InSight becomes one more step in an existing line. When they are not, they are the first thing to work out.

Common questions

Does InSight replace optical sorting?

No. The two address different quality characteristics and can be complementary.

Does sorting change the kernels?

No. InSight does not change the grain's protein. It separates the variation already present in the lot.

Does InSight measure the exact protein content of each kernel?

No. NIR-T provides a relative, protein-related measurement used to compare and classify kernels for sorting. It is not a laboratory measurement of each kernel's absolute protein content.

Which crops can InSight sort?

Wheat and barley.

From understanding to deciding

Understanding what InSight does differently is the first question. The second is whether that difference creates value for your grain, your target and your market.

That depends on more than the technology itself. In some cases, the commercial value may not justify the investment.

So, when does single-kernel sorting actually make business sense?

That's the question we'll explore next.

Have you signed up yet?

Don’t miss future updates, subscribe to our newsletter today.